Most contractors who come to Lemur Marketing with underperforming social accounts share the same problem: they’ve been watching the wrong numbers. Likes and follower counts feel good, but they rarely connect to booked jobs. The metrics that actually matter are less glamorous and far more actionable. Knowing which ones to track, and what to do when the numbers shift, is what separates a social presence that generates leads from one that just occupies time.
Reach and Impressions Are Not the Same Thing
Reach measures how many unique accounts saw a post. Impressions count every time that post appeared on a screen, including repeat views by the same person. For a remodeling contractor, reach is the more meaningful of the two. If 400 people in the Rolling Meadows area saw your before-and-after kitchen post, that’s 400 potential referral sources or future clients. If your impressions are three times your reach, it means the same small group is seeing your content repeatedly, which signals the algorithm is not distributing it to new audiences.
A healthy ratio depends on the platform. On Facebook and Instagram, an impressions-to-reach ratio above 1.5 over a 30-day period often indicates good content recycling. Above 3.0 with flat reach means your audience has stopped growing. That’s a distribution problem, not a content quality problem.
Engagement Rate Tells You What Reach Cannot

Engagement rate is calculated as total engagements divided by reach, expressed as a percentage. Comments, shares, saves, and direct message replies all count. Plain likes count less. Saves are particularly valuable for contractors because they signal genuine purchase intent. Someone saving a photo of a finished basement remodel is mentally filing it for later.
Lemur Marketing advises clients in Des Plaines, IL to aim for an engagement rate above 2% on Instagram and above 1% on Facebook for organic posts. Falling below those thresholds consistently means either the content isn’t connecting with the right audience or the posting schedule is off. Posting at 6 a.m. on a Tuesday when your followers are active on Thursday evenings will tank engagement regardless of content quality.
One metric worth adding to the mix: the share-to-like ratio. If a post gets 80 likes but only 2 shares, it’s appreciated but not compelling enough to pass along. Posts that get shared spread to cold audiences at zero cost. For remodeling contractors, project reveals and time-lapse videos consistently outperform static images on this metric.
Link Clicks and Profile Visits Connect Social to Real Business Outcomes
Engagement on its own is a vanity metric if it never moves anyone toward a conversation. Link clicks, profile visits, and direct message volume are the bridge between content performance and actual lead generation. These numbers live in the platform’s native analytics and are easy to overlook because they’re buried a few taps deeper than the like count.
Track link clicks weekly, not monthly. A sudden drop often corresponds to a change in post format, a shift in posting frequency, or an algorithm update. Monthly averages smooth over those drops and make it harder to diagnose what changed. Lemur Marketing sees this pattern constantly with contractors who review their analytics quarterly and then can’t pinpoint why a campaign stopped working three months ago.
Profile visits matter because many potential clients in Des Plaines, IL and the surrounding suburbs will visit a contractor’s profile before ever clicking a link or sending a message. A high profile visit count with low link clicks usually means the bio or pinned content isn’t compelling enough to push someone to the next step. That’s a fixable problem, and it doesn’t require more content creation.
If you’re running paid posts alongside organic content, tracking these metrics separately is non-negotiable. Paid reach inflates the overall numbers and can mask a failing organic strategy. For a deeper look at how paid placement fits into a contractor’s broader digital approach, social media services for contractors in the Elk Grove Village area outlines how the two work together.
Follower Growth Rate Matters More Than Follower Count
A contractor with 800 followers gaining 40 new followers per month is in better shape than one with 4,000 followers gaining 10. Growth rate, calculated as new followers divided by existing followers over a set period, tells you whether your content is pulling in new people or whether the account has plateaued.
Flat or declining follower counts in a market like the Des Plaines and Rolling Meadows corridor often mean the account is visible only to people who already know the business. That’s fine for retention, but it does nothing for new customer acquisition. Consistent growth, even slow growth, signals that content is reaching people outside the existing customer base.
One useful benchmark: a monthly follower growth rate of 3 to 5 percent is considered healthy for a local service business. Below 1 percent for three consecutive months warrants a content audit. Above 10 percent usually means a single viral post carried the number, and the underlying strategy may not be sustainable.
Tracking Social Media Marketing metrics without a clear framework leads to a lot of activity and very little insight. The numbers above give contractors a specific, repeatable way to evaluate what’s working before they spend more time or money on content that isn’t moving the needle.
Lemur Marketing is a digital marketing agency based in Des Plaines, IL that works specifically with home remodeling contractors. For questions about tracking and strategy, the team can be reached at 1574 Henry Ave, Des Plaines, IL 60016, (630) 551-8493.
Frequently Asked Questions
What metrics should I focus on to measure the effectiveness of my social media posts?
You should prioritize reach, engagement rate, link clicks, and profile visits. Reach shows how many unique accounts saw your content, while engagement rate indicates how well your audience is interacting. Link clicks and profile visits connect your social activity to actual business outcomes, helping you understand if your content is driving potential clients to take action.
How often should I track my social media metrics?
Track link clicks weekly instead of monthly to catch any sudden drops that could indicate a problem with your content or posting strategy. Monthly averages can obscure trends and make it difficult to pinpoint what changed. Regular monitoring allows you to adjust your tactics promptly.
What is a healthy follower growth rate for my business?
A healthy follower growth rate for a local service business is between 3 to 5 percent per month. If your growth rate falls below 1 percent for three consecutive months, it may be time for a content audit to evaluate what’s not working. Consistent growth is essential for reaching new clients beyond your existing customer base.
What common mistakes should I avoid when analyzing my social media metrics?
A common mistake is focusing too much on likes and follower counts, which don’t directly correlate with booked jobs. Instead, prioritize actionable metrics like engagement rates and link clicks. Additionally, failing to differentiate between paid and organic reach can lead to misinterpretation of your overall performance.
Get Directions to Lemur Marketing
🎧 Listen to this as a podcast
Also on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and Amazon Music.
